No. 8 Gotham FC secured their second playoff upset on Sunday, as a last-minute strike from forward Jaedyn Shaw earned the Bats a dramatic 1-0 semifinal win over the defending champion No. 4 Orlando Pride — and a ticket to next weekend's 2025 NWSL Championship.
The Pride had more chances throughout the closely contested match, but Shaw's masterful direct kick in second-half stoppage time ended Orlando's repeat bid.
"I'm grateful that everybody trusts me to step up in those moments," the 20-year-old midseason signee said postgame. "It starts on the training field, I feel the staff has really helped me improve my free kicks and all set pieces."
Also boosting Gotham's front line on Sunday was 2025 MVP finalist Esther, who returned to the starting lineup after missing the Bats' quarterfinal due to injury.
While Gotham saw the return of their season's top scorer, Orlando entered the match without Pride star striker Barbra Banda, ultimately failing to overcome her ongoing absence due to a midseason SEI.
"I think we were so resilient this season," Pride captain Marta said after the match. "Many people believed that we couldn't go so far, especially after we lost Barbra."
"[Gotham] have a good team, but we needed to be just a little bit more aggressive overall," she added. "We needed to put the ball in."
How to watch Gotham FC in the 2025 NWSL Championship
Sunday's result sends No. 8 Gotham FC to the 2025 NWSL Championship in San Jose, where they'll face the No. 2 Washington Spirit on Saturday.
The match kicks off at 8 PM ET, with live coverage airing on CBS.
No. 8-seed Gotham FC pulled off an historic upset on Sunday, downing the No. 1 Kansas City Current 2-1 in extra time to oust the winningest team in league history from the 2025 NWSL Playoffs.
Million-dollar midseason signing Jaedyn Shaw put the Bats on the board in the 68th minute, before Kansas City secured a second-half stoppage-time equalizer via defender Ellie Wheeler.
The match initially appeared destined for a penalty kick shootout, until late Gotham substitute Katie Stengel found the back of the net in the 121st minute — the latest game-winning goal in NWSL history.
"Underdog, my ass — we are not an underdog," Shaw exclaimed postmatch. "We came into this game knowing people thought that we were just the last seed that barely made it into the playoffs. That's not who we are."
The bid for the double never took flight for the 2025 Shield-winning Current, with key starting forwards 2024 MVP Temwa Chawinga and USWNT prospect Michelle Cooper ruled out with injury ahead of Sunday's quarterfinal clash.
In their stead, Kansas City forward Bia Zaneratto started the match despite dealing with an MCL sprain, gutting out 114 minutes before Bayley Fiest came in as relief.
"As much as we're disappointed in the final result today, we're not going to allow this result to define our season," said KC manager Vlatko Andonovski. "I think that our players, even today, can walk with their heads up."
How to watch Gotham in the 2025 NWSL semifinals
No. 8 Gotham now faces the defending champion No. 4 Orlando Pride in the 2025 NWSL semifinals — a club with whom the Bats split 2-0 regular-season results.
The match will kick of at 3 PM ET on Sunday, with live coverage airing on ABC.
As the NWSL enters the 2025 season's eighth match weekend, two teams at the top of the table are in unfamiliar territory: the loss column.
No. 1 Kansas City and No. 2 Orlando are both coming off upset losses, while No. 3 San Diego, No. 4 Gotham, and No. 5 Portland are rocketing up the ranks behind them.
This weekend, last year's top teams will either get back on track, or loosen their grip on this season's race to the Shield.
- No. 14 Chicago Stars vs. No. 6 Washington Spirit, Saturday at 12:50 PM ET (ABC): The Spirit have stumbled with two straight losses, leaving Washington looking to gain ground against a last-place Chicago side still reeling from head coach Lorne Donaldson's recent departure.
- No. 9 North Carolina Courage vs. No. 2 Orlando Pride, Saturday at 7:30 PM ET (ION): North Carolina is surging on a two-game winning streak, and will test their new success against a surprisingly fallible Orlando team with two losses in their last three games.
- No. 3 San Diego Wave vs. No. 5 Portland Thorns, Saturday at 10 PM ET (ION): The Wave and the Thorns have locked in over the last couple weeks, with a win for either club bolstering their case as a legitimate Shield contender.
- No. 1 Kansas City Current vs. No. 10 Bay FC, Sunday at 12:50 PM ET (ESPN): Kansas City has stalled after a blistering start, with the Current looking for their first win in three games against a Bay FC squad fighting to rise back above the playoff line.
League-wide parity has its benefits in the early days of the 2025 NWSL campaign, but season-long survival is on the line this weekend — with only so much room at the top.