The 2024 Ballon d’Or shortlist dropped yesterday, and while reigning winner Aitana Bonmatí as well as five USWNT athletes made the cut, defender Naomi Girma — considered by many to be the best center back in the world — was shockingly left off the 30-player list.
Seattle Reign head coach Laura Harvey was one of several notable figures to call out the snub, posting on X, “The ballon d’or is recognition of what? Is it domestic performances? Is it national team performances? Is it champions league performances? Because on the womens side how Naomi Girma isn’t nominated makes the whole thing hilarious.”
Girma's resume puts her squarely among the best
The 2022 NWSL Draft No. 1 pick has already racked up a full career's worth of accolades.
In her first professional season, Girma earned Rookie of the Year, Defender of the Year, and NWSL Best XI honors. She also helped her club, the San Diego Wave, win the 2023 NWSL Shield and 2024 NWSL Challenge Cup.
In 2023, Girma became the first defender ever named US Soccer’s Player of the Year. This summer, the 24 year old led the USWNT to Olympic gold as the only field athlete to play every single second of the 2024 Paris Games.
USWNT boss Emma Hayes called Girma “the best defender [she's] ever seen” during the Olympics, saying, “she's got everything: poise, composure, she can defend, she anticipates, she leads. [She's] unbelievable."
Ballon d'Or has a history of skipping over defenders
Awarded by French magazine France Football, the Ballon d’Or has long been criticized for heavily favoring athletes who play in Europe, and those who serve in an attacking capacity. Of the 30 2024 nominees, only seven play for clubs outside of Europe — six of them in the NWSL. Just four defenders — plus one goalkeeper, USWNT star Alyssa Naeher — made this year's cut.
In the award’s five-year history, only one defender has ever cracked the top three: England’s Lucy Bronze, who came in second to the USWNT’s Megan Rapinoe in 2019.
Ultimately, defense may win championships — but it has yet to win the Ballon d’Or.